eng

Blogs

Problems of the PPP Mechanism in Kazakhstan

11 August 2020

site

Dilyara Yakupova

Analyst

What is public-private partnership (PPP for short)? PPP is a form of mutually beneficial cooperation between a public authority and private sector by resources pooling to improve quality and availability of public goods and services. As of early August 2020, 1350 PPP projects were registered in Kazakhstan (of which 813 signed contracts; 283 at tender stage and 27 canceled contracts), and total amount of attracted and planned investments is about 1.1 trillion tenge. For this reason, it is relevant to study PPP mechanism of action and understand problematic issues. This article will cover some of them.

Firstly, PPP in Kazakhstan does not adequately reduce burden on the budget. The Ministry of National Economy divides PPP projects into 3 categories (category I - full reimbursement of investments and operating costs of a private partner from the budget; category II - partial recovery of investments from the budget; category III - without reimbursement from the budget). That is, for effective mechanism to reduce burden on the budget, preference should be given to the 3rd category of projects. At the same time, the share of projects in this category of the total number of concluded contracts is only 26% *. This means that a large number of PPP projects continue to be financed from budget funds, which does not significantly reduce burden on the budget. Despite the fact that over time the focus has shifted from “quantity” to “quality”, a large number of PPP projects are still funded from the budget.

Secondly, there are problems with understanding and interpreting legal framework governing PPPs. This is one of the reasons why some projects have been in competition / planning stage for many months and cannot reach contract conclusion stage. It should be noted that presence of a favorable regulatory framework is one of 5 most important factors of private investment attraction in PPPs in developing countries.

Thirdly, at the moment in Kazakhstan there is a rather narrow coverage of sectors with PPP projects, and experience of more “successful” projects is not sufficiently translated into other areas. For example, PPP projects in 3 sectors account for about 75% of all projects being implemented. Education sector alone makes up 55% of all projects, while among planned projects it also occupies a leading share at 52%. On the one hand, this indicates success of some industries, on the other, potential for study of successful cases of PPP projects implementation in other areas.

* as of the end of July 2019
** as of early August 2020

Sources:
1. MNE RK
2. Kazakhstan PPP Center
3. Factors Attracting Private Sector Investments in Public–Private Partnerships in Developing Countries: A Survey of International Experts. 2017. DOI: 10.1108/JFMPC-06-2016-0026

all publications

Reports

more

Blogs

more

News

more
site